SENATOR THE HON ANNE RUSTON

SHADOW MINISTER FOR HEALTH AND AGED CARE

DEPUTY LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION IN THE SENATE

SENATOR FOR SOUTH AUSTRALIA

MEDIA RELEASE

Wednesday, 18 November 2026

LABOR’S NUMBERS DON’T ADD UP: NEARLY EIGHT TIMES MORE SENIORS SET TO DUMP PRIVATE COVER AND PUT MORE PRESSURE ON PUBLIC SYSTEM

New independent research shows nearly eight times as many older Australians would drop their private health insurance under the Albanese Government’s rebate cut as Labor has admitted, blowing apart the modelling the Government is relying on to force its $11 billion pensioner tax through the Senate in the final sitting fortnight of the year.

An Ipsos survey of 2,148 private health policyholders, commissioned by Members Health Fund Alliance, found 12.1 per cent of Australians aged 65 and over would drop their cover if the cut goes ahead.

A further 12.2 per cent would downgrade their cover, 8.9 per cent would raise their excess or cut their benefits and 11.3 per cent would switch insurers. In total, almost half of older policyholders say they would be forced to change their cover, and more than 80 per cent of Australians aged 65 and over oppose the cut.

This is in contrast Labor’s modelling which assumes just 0.4 per cent, or around 44,000 people would drop their cover in 2028-29. Following a Freedom on Information request, it was revealed the drop out figure rises to nearly 80,000 by 2030. The Government has also failed to provide any modelling regarding the number of people expected to downgrade their cover.

Shadow Minister for Health and Aged Care, Senator Anne Ruston, said the research was the latest in a long line of evidence exposing Labor’s figures as fiction.

“Labor has spent months telling Australians that only 44,000 older people would walk away from their cover. Labor’s claims don’t survive contact with reality,” Senator Ruston said.

“First Medibank put it at up to 91,000. Then documents released under Freedom of Information showed the Minister’s own Department expects 78,000 by 2029-30. Catholic Health Australia warned of 665,000 downgrades. Now Ipsos tells us more than 330,000 older policyholders would drop their cover tomorrow.

“This is lazy legislation, built on lazy assumptions, from a lazy minister. Labor didn’t bother to count the pensioners it was hitting, and it still hasn’t counted the people it is pushing out of private cover.”

Senator Ruston said every older Australian who drops or downgrades their cover would still need their new hip, their cataract surgery or their cancer treatment.

“They don’t stop needing care. They just join the back of the public hospital queue. This isn’t a saving, it’s a cost shift from Canberra onto state hospitals, and it is older Australians who will pay more, wait longer and get less,” Senator Ruston said.

No State or Territory has supported Labor’s Bill.

“The Minister says this was a hard choice. He’s forcing older Australians into much harder choices about their healthcare. Mark Butler needs to drop these ill-conceived and punitive cuts today and walk away.

“Every Senator who votes for this Bill is voting to put up private health premiums for older Australians who did the right thing their whole lives.”

ENDS

Stay in the loop